Markets move up and down — that’s a fact. Emotional reactions to those movements, however, are optional. But even the most analytical, financially literate clients are not immune to anxiety, fear, or regret. When emotions take hold, investors tend to lose perspective. They start zeroing in on recent losses, alarming headlines, or isolated data points rather than the big-picture goal or why they started initially investing.
To appease clients, financial advisors often respond with more information like additional charts, statistics, and explanations. Yet when a client is emotionally activated, more detail fuels the fire, further pushing the client toward the very thing that triggered them. As I’ve noted in previous blogs, it’s important for advisors to address clients’ emotional triggers, lest they manifest as risk aversion in portfolio design and undermine long-term returns.
That’s where chunking up comes in. This technique, drawn from cognitive psychology and widely used in athletic coaching, allows investors to reconnect with long-term reasoning, reduce emotional stress, and make decisions aligned with their goals rather than their fears.
What follows is a practical framework for financial advisors, supported by client–advisor dialogues, illustrating how to guide clients toward steadier thinking amid inevitable market swings.
Chunking Up for the Win
Chunking involves grouping information into more meaningful patterns to make sense of more complex ideas. But when markets turn volatile, it’s easy for clients to get lost in the details, or chunk down.
Hence:
- Chunking down: focusing on specifics
- Chunking up: redirecting attention to broader intentions, values, or goals
An advisor “chunks up” by steering clients away from emotionally charged details and back to the higher-level purpose behind their investments, restoring balance and strengthening long-term decision-making.
A parallel example appears in sports. When an athlete misses a shot or loses a match, their attention often narrows to the mistake itself, a classic example of chunking down.
A skilled coach reframes the moment by shifting the athlete’s attention from the error to the broader objective, such as the team’s overall strategy. This chunking up process diffuses emotional reactivity and promotes mental clarity.
Under stress, investors behave similarly. They magnify a short-term loss, a colleague’s poor experience, or a negative headline, losing sight of the broader plan.
Chunking up reverses this effect. It draws attention away from the immediate trigger and back to strategy. Its power lies in how it reshapes mental processing, encouraging clients to re-engage in long-term reasoning and escape the cognitive traps that lead to poor strategizing.
A Practical Framework
Advisors can use the following process to move clients from emotional reactivity to goal-aligned reasoning. Each step builds on the last, guiding the conversation from detail to direction.
- Identify the emotional anchor: Pinpoint the detail dominating the client’s attention: a recent loss, a worrying headline, or a peer’s negative experience. Recognizing the anchor informs what’s driving the reaction.
- Chunk up with one question: Introduce a higher-level question that reframes perspective, such as:
- What was the purpose behind this choice?
- What long-term goal does this relate to?
- What were we trying to achieve originally?
This simple pivot interrupts the emotional loop and opens the path to broader, more rational reasoning.
- Connect to values and objectives: Link the discussion back to what truly matters, the client’s long-term goals, priorities, and values. Re-centering on long-term plans (retirement security, independence, family legacy) reactivates purpose and steadies perspective.
- Reevaluate through the higher frame: With emotions quelled, you can guide clients to reassess choices through this broader lens. Urgency tends to fade once context is restored. Fear often dissolves at this stage.
- Then return to specifics: With perspective regained, revisit allocations, timing, risk level, and implementation. Clients are calmer and better equipped to make decisions aligned with their long-term objectives.
This sequence transforms reactive moments into opportunities for clarity, trust, and insight. In an environment defined by uncertainty, chunking up is one of the most valuable skills an advisor can master.
In Practice: Two Client Dialogues
Case 1: Fear of Regret (Regret Aversion)
Client: I’m afraid of making the wrong call. What if we allocate to equities now and markets drop?
Advisor (chunking up): I understand. Let’s step back for a moment. What’s the bigger purpose you’re trying to serve with this allocation?
Client: To make my money work better than it currently does.
Advisor: And is the goal to avoid temporary declines, or to grow capital over 10–15 years?
Client: Growing capital.
Advisor: So which choice supports that purpose more: staying fully safe, or taking measured risk?
Client: Taking some risk.
Advisor: Exactly. From there, we can explore how much risk feels appropriate.
Key takeaway: The client’s fear wasn’t about equities; it was about regret. Chunking up surfaced the deeper intention behind the emotion.
Case 2: Recency Bias After a Negative Headline
Client: I’ve read another article predicting a recession. We should pause all contributions.
Advisor (chunking up): Totally understand that instinct. Let me ask, what’s your primary goal with these monthly contributions?
Client: To build enough for financial independence.
Advisor: And is financial independence something that depends on one quarter or on decades?
Client: Decades.
Advisor: So if your goal is decades-long independence, how does stopping contributions after one article support or hinder that?
Client: …It might actually hurt it.
Advisor: Exactly. Shall we look at how disciplined contributions have performed historically during volatile periods?
Key takeaway: The advisor avoided debating the headline, likely a losing game, and reconnected the strategy to the client’s true anchor: financial independence.
Turning Anxiety into Insight
In a profession where uncertainty is constant, the ability to reframe emotion is invaluable. By mastering chunking up, advisors can transform anxious reactions into meaningful dialogue, allowing clients to follow a plan grounded in purpose rather than panic. A single well-timed question can be the bridge between fear and focus and is the mark of an advisor who truly leads with clarity.
